DY Chandrachud: Was India's top judge an icon or a pushover?

Justice DY Chandrachud's retirement as India's Chief Justice marks a significant moment in the country’s judiciary history. Appointed as the 50th Chief Justice of India, his tenure has been a subject of much debate and discussion, leaving a legacy that has inspired some and displeased others. This mixed reception leads to the question: Was Justice Chandrachud an icon of the judiciary, or did his tenure reveal him to be a pushover? Justice Dhananjaya Yeshwant Chandrachud, known for his progressive and liberal judgments, has been at the forefront of some of the most pivotal rulings in recent Indian judicial history. From the right to privacy and decriminalizing homosexuality to the contentious issue of women’s entry into Sabarimala temple, his contributions have been groundbreaking. Yet, it is this very progression that has drawn criticism from various quarters, suggesting perhaps, a polarized view of his tenure. **A Champion for Individual Rights** Justice Chandrachud's tenure was marked by a strong emphasis on protecting individual rights, which resonated well with the citizens seeking progressive changes within society. His ruling on the Right to Privacy as a fundamental right under the Constitution of India has been hailed as a landmark decision, affirming the importance of personal freedom and autonomy. This judgment set a precedent for future cases involving privacy concerns, including matters related to Aadhaar, the biometric identification project. In another historic verdict, the bench led by Justice Chandrachud dec